---

Detailed Breakdown:

This passage presents a philosophical exploration of the tension between doing (taking action) and being (existing or experiencing life without striving). The speaker critiques the motivational aspects of goal-setting, suggesting that many goals are driven by a sense of lack, a feeling that something is missing in one’s life. They argue that these goals, rather than coming from a place of self-fulfillment, might emerge from an unconscious desire to create or strengthen an identity based on external achievements.

The discussion revolves around the root of ambition and how it may be tied to a feeling of incompleteness rather than a connection to one’s true self or a higher purpose. The speaker contrasts doing (striving for goals) with being (existing in the present, accepting oneself as whole), suggesting that true fulfillment may not lie in achieving external goals, but in aligning with an internal sense of purpose and connection.

---

Key Concepts:

1. The Struggle Between Doing and Being:
   • The primary theme of the passage is the dichotomy between action (doing) and existence (being). The speaker asks why we engage in action, suggesting that it often stems from a feeling of lack—the belief that something is missing, and thus we must act to fill that void.
   • Doing is framed as an attempt to achieve something external (a goal or an identity) because, in the moment, there’s an internal sense of incompleteness or desire for improvement.
   • Being, on the other hand, is about accepting the present moment and recognizing that we are complete as we are, without needing to prove anything or chase after external validation.
2. Goal Setting and Its Connection to Lack:
   • The speaker critiques traditional goal-setting by pointing out that goals are often based on the premise of lacking something—whether it’s success, knowledge, or approval. This perspective implies that the pursuit of goals comes from a place of insecurity or lack of fulfillment.
   • For example, people often strive to educate themselves, achieve career goals, or acquire wealth, not necessarily because they are connected to their purpose, but because they feel these things will fill a void or help them establish a desired identity.
3. The Identity We Build Through Doing:
   • The passage suggests that the ambition to achieve often arises from the desire to create an identity—one that aligns with societal expectations or personal desires. This identity may represent something that a person thinks they should be, but it may not reflect their true essence or an authentic connection to who they really are.
   • In this sense, doing becomes a tool to construct an identity that is outwardly recognized, but may not necessarily reflect inner fulfillment or connection to the source (the inner self or higher purpose).
4. Connection to the Source:
   • The speaker introduces the concept of being connected to the source—the idea that there is nothing to add or subtract from one’s true self. From this perspective, doing to achieve goals becomes less important, as the sense of completeness is already present within. The true fulfillment and purpose come from aligning with this connection, not from external achievements.
   • Being in alignment with the source means recognizing that you are inherently complete, not needing to achieve anything in the external world to feel whole or validated.

---

Expert Analysis:

1. The Philosophy of Doing vs. Being:

The distinction between doing and being is central to many philosophical traditions, including existentialism and Eastern philosophies like Taoism and Buddhism. The struggle between action and existence is often seen as part of the human condition, with the former focused on achieving external goals and the latter focused on inner peace and acceptance.

• Existential Thought: In existential philosophy, the tension between doing (action) and being (existence) often reflects the search for meaning. Existentialists like Jean-Paul Sartre and Martin Heidegger argue that we are always in the process of defining ourselves through our actions, yet they caution against becoming too absorbed in external actions that disconnect us from the more authentic aspects of being—our true self, not defined by external expectations or goals.
• Eastern Influence: In contrast, Eastern philosophies like Taoism and Buddhism emphasize the importance of being in the present moment. The Taoist ideal of “wu wei” (effortless action) suggests that individuals can achieve more by not forcing their will onto the world but rather by being in harmony with the flow of life. This contrasts with a Western approach to success, which often emphasizes relentless doing and achieving as the primary route to fulfillment.

2. Goal Setting and the Psychology of Lack:

The idea that goals are often driven by lack is a psychological observation rooted in self-determination theory (SDT), which suggests that people are motivated by the need to fulfill three basic psychological needs: autonomy, competence, and relatedness. When individuals perceive a lack in one of these areas, they may seek external goals (money, success, approval) as a way to fill that void.

• Psychological Need for Fulfillment: Goals grounded in lack may be reactive rather than proactive, arising from deficit-driven motivation rather than authentic desire or growth. For instance, someone might pursue a high-paying job not because it aligns with their passions, but because they feel inadequate without financial security or status.
• Authentic Goals: A key aspect of fulfilling goal-setting is to move away from external validation and focus on intrinsic motivation—goals that come from an authentic place of self-expression and growth. This shift can help prevent the constant chasing of external markers of success and instead foster a sense of personal fulfillment and inner peace.

3. The Creation of Identity Through Achievement:

The idea that doing stems from a desire to create an identity is a core concept in social psychology. Erik Erikson’s theory of psychosocial development suggests that identity formation is a crucial part of human development, particularly during adolescence and young adulthood. The tension between our social identities (shaped by achievements and societal roles) and our personal identity (authentically aligned with our core self) can create conflict.

• Social Identity Theory: According to Henri Tajfel and John Turner, individuals define themselves in part through the groups they belong to, which often include accomplishments, careers, or social roles. The desire to achieve and be recognized stems from the need to validate these social identities, even if they are disconnected from our true selves.
• Authentic Self: An important insight from humanistic psychology, particularly the work of Carl Rogers, is the distinction between the ideal self (who we want to be) and the real self (who we truly are). Achieving external goals might bring us closer to our ideal self, but it’s critical to recognize that true fulfillment comes from reconciling these identities and moving towards a life that reflects the real self.

---

Conclusion:

This passage delves deeply into the philosophical and psychological implications of ambition, goal-setting, and the dichotomy between doing and being. The speaker suggests that much of our external striving stems from a sense of lack, where individuals chase goals not to enhance their inner lives but to create or reinforce an identity. True fulfillment, however, comes from aligning with an internal sense of purpose and being, rather than from constantly pursuing external achievements. By reflecting on this tension, individuals may find more meaningful ways to approach life that prioritize self-acceptance and authenticity over achievement and external validation.